Man United Coach Criticized for ‘Bizarre’ Rant Amid PL Decline

Ange ‘on thin ice’ after 3-2 loss | 03:26

Ruben Amorim might not have been historically accurate when he labelled his Manchester United flops as “maybe the worst team” in the club’s history, but his astonishing claim did expose the extent of the problems facing the beleaguered boss.

Watch every ball of The 2025 Women’s Ashes Series LIVE with no ad-breaks during play on Kayo | New to Kayo? Get your first month for just $1. Limited time offer.

Amorim responded to United’s dismal 3-1 home defeat against Brighton on Sunday by branding his players among the worst in the club’s illustrious history.

United are languishing in 13th place in the Premier League and have endured a painful series of ignominious losses since Amorim arrived from Sporting Lisbon to replace the sacked Erik ten Hag in November.

Already in disarray prior to Amorim’s appointment, United have stumbled from one calamity to another under the Portuguese coach, with only rare signs of optimism in their draw at Liverpool and FA Cup win over Arsenal with 10 men.

United have suffered six home league defeats this season, their most from their opening 12 matches since the 1893-94 campaign.

They have also lost 10 of their 22 league games this term, the earliest into a top-flight season that they have hit double figures for defeats since 1989-90.

Heralded as one of the brightest young coaches in the game after a successful spell with Sporting, Amorim is now beginning to understand exactly why United have gone 12 years since winning the most recent of their record 20 English titles.

The 39-year-old’s brutal assessment pulled back the curtain on the depth of United’s decline since legendary boss Alex Ferguson ended his golden era after that 2013 title triumph.

“Our players are really nervous in actions,” Amorim said.

“When you go on the pitch you remember the last games here.

“If I feel it, the players feel it a lot. The only way is to continue to do the same and to win games, that’s the only way to fix this.”

Amorim is now feeling the heat from all directions.

Former Liverpool defender-turned analyst for Sky Sports Jamie Carragher expressed his astonishment at the United coach’s actions.

“It was one of the most bizarre and ridiculous things I’ve heard a manager say,” Carragher said.

“That’s the type of comment a pundit would make… I don’t know what he gains from it and what the benefit is. That will be a quote that will follow him for the remainder of the season.

“I don’t have much sympathy for the players in that Man United dressing room. They’ve been a joke for a few years now… But what I would say is from the manager’s point of view, how can he go into the dressing room for the rest of the season and continually try and build them up and give them belief if he’s said they are the worst team in Man United history.

“At no point do I see what he was going to gain from that.”

Former England striker Alan Shearer believes Man United are even worse under Amorim than they were under Ten Hag.

“They’re actually worse now than they were under Ten Hag, because of what this manager wants to do with this system. The way he wants to play, the players just can’t do it,” Shearer said on the Rest is Football podcast.

“You sort of get and understand why he is saying that, to buy himself time. It’s so unusual that you’ve got one of, if not, the biggest club in the world and the manager is coming out and saying ‘this is the worst side in their history’ because of where they are and some of their performances.

“Last week and the week before, we were saying how well they performed at Arsenal and how well they performed at Liverpool. Yet, a week later, he is coming out and saying they are the worst in their history, it’s incredible.

“It’s a really tough one to understand because he’s got a bit of a free pass, because of how bad it has been there.”

Sky Sports’ Michael Dawson also went in on Amorim for his post-game comments.

“I’m not sure I’d be happy if my manager came out and said that,” Dawson said.

“This is becoming embarrassing.”

Chief Man United writer Samuel Luckhurst went a few steps further, calling the current squad one of the worst “in anyone’s lifetime”. A huge call considering the long and proud history of the club.

Amorim is paying the price for United’s muddled recruitment policy in recent years.

Harry Maguire, Rasmus Hojlund, Antony, Casemiro, Andre Onana and Joshua Zirkzee have all failed to justify hefty transfer fees, leaving Amorim with an unbalanced squad that cannot meet his demand for a high-energy 3-4-3 formation.

British billionaire Jim Ratcliffe and his legion of advisers have hardly made a positive impression since the INEOS boss became United’s co-owner last year.

They dithered over Ten Hag’s future after last season’s surprise FA Cup final win against Manchester City, eventually opting to keep the Dutchman despite speaking to Thomas Tuchel about replacing him.

When Ten Hag struggled again this season, Ratcliffe axed him in October, only to then fire sporting director Dan Ashworth after just five months in the role.

Unable to turn the tide, Amorim’s blunt criticism of United could be seen as a message to Ratcliffe to spend on new signings before the January transfer window closes.

United’s current 13th place would equal their lowest finish since 1989-90, while their tally of 26 points from 22 games is eight fewer than at this stage of any previous season since 1992.

Last season, they finished eighth, which ranked as their worst final position since 1990.

Manchester Utd players cut dejected figures after their shock loss to Brighton over the weekend.Source: AFP

Despite those damning numbers, United historians could make a case to disagree with Amorim’s “worst team” claim on a purely statistical level.

United have been relegated from the top-flight five times, a fate surely even Amorim’s woeful squad are unlikely to suffer as they sit 10 points above the drop zone.

Their most recent relegation came in 1973-74 when United legend Denis Law returned to Old Trafford with Manchester City to score the goal that rubber-stamped a fate already sealed by results elsewhere.

It was especially ironic that United hit their latest low point against Brighton on the day they paid tribute to Law, who passed away aged 84 on Friday.

Law, Bobby Charlton and George Best became known as United’s ‘Holy Trinity’ after spearheading their rise to European Cup glory in 1968 from the ashes of the Munich plane crash that killed eight members of Matt Busby’s team 10 years earlier.

Leading United to Champions League glory must seem a long way off for Amorim as he comes to terms with the size of the task facing him at Old Trafford.